Category : Investing Insights August 7, 20245 minutes read
Understanding XIRR vs CAGR is vital for any investor trying to maintain a portfolio. They are two important investment return metrics that differ in their calculation and use. The main difference is that XIRR calculates annualised return based on the timing and amounts of actual cash flows, while CAGR simplifies total return into an annualised growth rate between the start and end values. XIRR may be better for irregular investments with detailed cash flow data, while CAGR may be suitable for regular investments focused on long-term growth. When comparing CAGR vs XIRR, it’s important to note that CAGR offers a simple annual growth rate, while XIRR provides a more complex return calculation for varying cash flows.
XIRR and CAGR both have their merits depending on the investment. For irregular investments with detailed cash flow data, XIRR is often more useful and accurate than CAGR since it accounts for the timing and size of all cash inflows and outflows. However, for regular investments focused on long-term growth, CAGR may be sufficient and easier to calculate.
Whether a 12% XIRR is considered good depends on factors like the specific type of investment, the level of risk involved, and other available investment opportunities. A 12% XIRR would be deemed relatively healthy, but an even higher XIRR would be preferred for higher-risk investments like venture capital. XIRR in SIP is crucial for understanding the actual return on investments.
Yes, XIRR represents an investment’s annualised internal rate of return over its lifetime. It considers the timing and amounts of all cash flows to calculate the annualised IRR.
A 5-year CAGR calculates the constant annual growth rate of an investment achieved over a 5-year time period. It averages out the total return to smooth out any volatility and arrive at an annualised growth rate across the 5 years.
A very high XIRR, like 99%, likely indicates that the cash flows used in the calculation had a very quick payback period compared to the original investment outlay. This means the investment achieved returns extremely fast compared to capital deployed. The high XIRR implies exceptionally fast returns but should be validated with proper data.
Introduction
At first glance, they may seem similar in assessing the profitability of an investment. However, XIRR (Extended Internal Rate of Return) and CAGR (Compound Annual Growth Rate) have distinct methodologies and applications. Investors must understand the key differences between the concepts to analyse investment opportunities accurately. In the context of CAGR vs XIRR for SIP, XIRR is more suitable as it accurately reflects the varying investment amounts and periods typical of SIPs.
This article will shed light on the XIRR vs CAGR debate, how they are calculated, their limitations, and when it is appropriate to use each metric. We will explore the main differences between XIRR vs CAGR and when one has an advantage over the other depending on the type of investment and cash flow data available.
Before dwelling into the differences between XIRR vs CAGR, it is necessary to understand the meaning of XIRR. XIRR (Extended Internal Rate of Return) is one of the most useful metrics when assessing investment returns. As the name suggests, XIRR measures the annualised internal rate of return (IRR) for investments with multiple cash inflows and outflows over time.
What is XIRR in Mutual Funds?
What does XIRR mean? It stands for Extended Internal Rate of Return, a financial measure used to calculate returns on investments with non-uniform cash flows. XIRR in mutual funds provides the true annualised yield of an investment by considering the specific timing and size of each cash transaction. The XIRR formula utilises the actual dates and amounts of all cash flows to calculate the IRR mathematically. It provides a more accurate view than simple ROI calculations, which only use initial and final values. What is XIRR return? It represents the annualized rate of return accounting for cash flow timing, making it more precise for irregular investments.
XIRR Formula
The XIRR formula equates the present value of the periodic cash flows to zero as follows:
XIRR = IRR(values, dates)
Where:
Values = Array of all cash flows (negative for investments, positive for returns)
Dates = Array of dates corresponding to each cash flow
Limitations of XIRR
To accurately compare XIRR vs CAGR, analysing the drawbacks and limitations are necessary. While XIRR is an extremely useful metric, it does have some limitations to be aware of:
- Requires high-quality cash flow data: XIRR is only as accurate as the cash flow data used in the calculation. Any missing or inaccurate values can skew the final XIRR result.
- Assumes reinvestment at XIRR rate: The XIRR result essentially assumes reinvestment of returns at the calculated XIRR rate rather than the actual varying reinvestment rate.
- Sensitive to small data changes: Even small tweaks to the timing or amounts of cash flows can significantly impact the final XIRR.
- Works best for varied cash flows: For investments with very regular cash flows, other metrics may be more appropriate than XIRR. You can also use XIRR SIP calculator for investors to determine the internal rate of return on their Systematic Investment Plan contributions
Overall, when detailed cash flow data is available, XIRR is an invaluable metric for assessing irregular investment types like private equity, venture capital, and real estate investments. The key difference between XIRR and CAGR lies in their application: XIRR is suitable for investments like SIPs with regular intervals, whereas CAGR is suited for lumpsum investment.
XIRR measures the annualised internal rate of return (IRR) for investments with multiple cash inflows and outflows over time. The XIRR formula utilises the actual dates and amounts of all cash flows to calculate the IRR mathematically. It provides a more accurate view than simple ROI calculations. However, XIRR may have certain limitations, it requires high-quality cash flow data, assumes reinvestment at XIRR rate, sensitive to small data changes, and is usually suitable for varied cash flows.
To effectively compare XIRR vs CAGR it is necessary to accurately understand the meaning of CAGR. CAGR stands for Compound Annual Growth Rate. As the name denotes, CAGR measures the annualised rate of return of an investment over a specific time period. What is CAGR growth rate? It’s a calculation that shows the mean annual growth rate of an investment over a specified time period under the assumption of reinvestment.
What is the CAGR in Mutual Funds?
CAGR in mutual funds calculates the constant annual growth rate that would produce the cumulative total return of the investment over the period measured. It smooths out the volatility in returns to show a steady growth rate.
Start investing in mutual funds for the long-term & potentially reduce the risk of volatility.
CAGR Formula
The CAGR formula is simple:
CAGR = (Ending Value / Beginning Value) ^ (1/Number of Years) – 1
Where:
Ending Value = The final value of the investment
Beginning Value = The original investment amount
Number of Years = Length of time period measured
Limitations of CAGR
Now that we understand the formula of CAGR and XIRR, let’s look at the limitations of CAGR. While easy to calculate, high CAGR mutual funds do have some limitations to consider:
- Ignores volatility: CAGR does not consider any fluctuations in returns during the period. The growth may not have actually been smooth and steady.
- Cannot assume future rate: The CAGR should not necessarily be assumed as the expected growth going forward. Past returns do not guarantee future performance.
Overall, CAGR serves as a good summary metric of growth over a defined period for regular investments. However, it should be used cautiously for investments with irregular cash flows or volatility. It also should not be relied upon as a predictive rate for future expected returns.
The difference between XIRR and CAGR lies in their calculation methods; CAGR is used for uniform investments, while XIRR is for variable cash flows. Mentioned below are some of the other key differences between these two:
| Metric | XIRR | CAGR |
| Meaning | Internal rate of return based on cash flows. | Annual growth rate between start & end values. |
| Formula | IRR calculation using timing & amounts of cash flows. XIRR formula is XIRR = IRR(values, dates). | Calculates annual growth needed to achieve total return. CAGR formula is CAGR = (Ending Value / Beginning Value) ^ (1/Number of Years) – 1 |
| Use Case | Irregular investments with detailed cash flow data. | Regular investments focused on long-term growth. |
| User | Venture capital, private equity investors. | Mutual fund investors, retail investors. |
| Drawbacks | Data-intensive, assumes reinvestment at XIRR, sensitive. | Ignores volatility, cannot predict future. |
In summary, CAGR meaning in mutual fund investment is essential as it provides a quick snapshot of how much the fund has grown on an annual basis. XIRR is more applicable for irregular investments with access to quality cash flow data. It provides a better representation of returns but requires more input. CAGR is easier to calculate but better suits smoother investments over the long term.
To summarise the XIRR vs CAGR debate:
- XIRR formula calculates the annualised internal rate of return based on the timing and amounts of actual cash flows. It is better suited for irregular investments where cash flow data is available.
- CAGR formula calculates the annual growth rate between the start and end values of an investment. It is simpler and easier to use for regular investments focused on long-term growth.
- XIRR provides a more accurate return metric for investments with varied cash inflows and outflows over time. CAGR gives a smoother annualised growth rate summary.
- XIRR requires detailed cash flow data to be accurate. CAGR only needs the beginning and ending values.
- For SIPs, XIRR better reflects the variable contribution amounts and timing. CAGR simplifies returns into a steady growth rate.
- CAGR ignores volatility, whereas XIRR accounts for fluctuations in cash flows.
- CAGR should not be assumed as a guaranteed future growth rate. XIRR assumes reinvestment at the XIRR rate.
In summary, both XIRR and CAGR offer valuable insights into investment returns from different perspectives. Understanding when to apply each method allows for better evaluation of opportunities and performance. Investors should utilise the appropriate metric and be aware of the limitations.
