Category : Investing Guides October 9, 20255 minutes read
While choosing methods to invest in mutual funds, investors may compare SIP vs STP. SIP (Systematic Investment Plan) and STP (Systematic Transfer Plan) are two approaches to investing in mutual funds, each suited to different financial strategies. SIP allows investors to make regular, fixed investments over time, making it a potentially suitable choice for those looking to build wealth gradually. STP, on the other hand, may be a suitable investment option for investors who want to transfer their funds from one scheme to another—typically from debt to equity or vice versa—to manage risks or potentially capitalise on market conditions. The choice between SIP and STP depends on your financial goals and needs: SIP may be preferred for long-term, consistent investments, while STP may be better for optimising returns and managing market volatility.
When it comes to mutual fund investments, SIP (Systematic Investment Plan) and STP (Systematic Transfer Plan) are two methods that serve different purposes. An SIP involves making regular, fixed investments into a mutual fund, which is a viable investment option for individuals looking to potentially build wealth gradually by averaging out market volatility over time. On the other hand, an STP allows investors to transfer a fixed amount of money from one mutual fund scheme to another, usually from a debt fund to an equity fund or vice versa, to better manage risk and optimise potential returns.
In this guide, we will explore the key differences between SIP and STP, how each investment method works, and which might be a better option for investors. We’ll also discuss the steps involved in setting up an STP, the benefits of STP in mutual funds, and ultimately, compare SIP vs STP, and determine which may be better for a specific investment goal and strategy.
A Systematic Investment Plan (SIP) allows you to invest a fixed amount in mutual funds at regular intervals—monthly, quarterly, or weekly. By spreading out investments over time, SIP helps reduce the impact of market fluctuations. Funds are automatically debited from your account and invested, allowing you to build wealth consistently without trying to time the market.
Now, let’s understand the advantages of SIP, some of which are discussed below:
Rupee Cost Averaging
SIP helps average the cost of investments over time, buying more units when prices are low and fewer when prices are high, reducing the impact of market volatility.
Disciplined Investing
SIP promotes consistent, automatic investing, helping you stay on track with your financial goals regardless of market conditions, and minimising emotional decisions.
Affordability and Flexibility
With SIP, you can start small (with amounts as low as ₹500) and adjust contributions as needed. It’s flexible, making it a good choice for beginners and seasoned investors alike.
Learn more about the benefits of SIP!
Unlock the benefits of Rupee Cost Averaging by starting an SIP with Bandhan Mutual Fund.
Systematic Investment Plans (SIPs) are an investment method in which you can invest in mutual funds at regular intervals. SIPs have several benefits; investors may benefit from Rupee Cost Averaging and disciplined investing in the long run. SIPs are also affordable, with the minimum investment being as low as ₹500. This investment amount can be changed or stopped at any time, making it a flexible investment as well.
A Systematic Transfer Plan (STP) lets you transfer a fixed amount of money from one mutual fund, typically a debt fund, to another, like an equity fund, at regular intervals. This gradual shift helps investors avoid moving large sums during market volatility. STP offers flexibility in setting the frequency of transfers, making it a useful tool for portfolio rebalancing.
Discussed below are some of the advantages of STP:
May reduce exposure to volatility
STP may reduce market timing risk by spreading out investments over time, limiting the impact of sudden market fluctuations.
Potential Tax Efficiency
By transferring funds gradually, STP can help manage tax liabilities more efficiently, with only the transferred portion subject to capital gains tax.
Averaging Risk
Similar to SIP, STP helps average out risk by spreading the transfer of funds across different market conditions, ensuring smoother portfolio management.
| Parameters | Systematic Investment Plan | Systematic Transfer Plan |
| Meaning | SIP is a method of regularly investing a fixed amount into a mutual fund scheme over time. | STP allows transferring a fixed amount from one mutual fund to another, usually from a debt fund to an equity fund, at regular intervals. |
| Purpose | SIP may help in building wealth gradually by investing consistently over time, regardless of market conditions. | STP is designed to manage market risk by moving funds between schemes to reduce exposure to volatility. It’s typically used to transfer from debt to equity. |
| Taxation | SIP is taxed based on capital gains rules, with long-term and short-term capital gains applying depending on the holding period. | In STP, each transfer is treated as a redemption from the source fund, subject to capital gains tax. This can be more tax-efficient if shifting from debt to equity. |
| Suitability | SIP is a good choice for investors with regular income who prefer disciplined investing for long-term growth. | STP is suited for investors who already have a lumpsum and want to rebalance their portfolio or manage risk by moving between schemes. |
| Initial Investment | SIP allows investors to start small, with amounts as low as Rs 500, making it affordable and flexible. | STP requires an initial lump-sum investment in the source fund, often a debt fund before transfers can begin. |
No one investment method is inherently better than the other. Whether SIP or STP is more suitable depends on the individual investor’s financial situation, goals, and risk tolerance. The difference between SIP and STP lies in how they help investors manage their money—SIP is better suited for those who want to invest gradually, while STP is useful for those looking to rebalance their funds or move a lumpsum over time.
Salaried Individuals
For salaried individuals with a regular income, SIP may often be a better fit. By committing to invest a small amount regularly, salaried investors can benefit from disciplined investing without worrying about timing the market. SIP also offers flexibility, allowing investors to adjust their investments according to their financial capacity while gradually building wealth.
Lumpsum Investors
For lumpsum investors, STP may be a suitable way to enter the market cautiously. Instead of putting a large sum into equities all at once, they can use STP in mutual funds to stagger their entry into the stock market, reducing the risk of volatility. This gradual transfer from a debt fund or an existing equity fund to an equity fund can help balance risk and provide tax efficiency benefits.
Risk Tolerance
When it comes to risk tolerance, SIP may often be favoured by more risk-averse investors who prefer consistent, long-term growth with less exposure to market fluctuations. On the other hand, STP may suit those who have a higher risk tolerance and want the flexibility to manage a lumpsum more strategically.
Ultimately, deciding which is better: SIP or STP depends on individual needs. The benefits of STP in mutual funds cater to those with lumpsums looking for risk control, while SIP may be a preferable option for those who want to build their portfolio with regular, smaller contributions.
- SIP (Systematic Investment Plan) allows regular, fixed investments in mutual funds, which are good for gradual wealth accumulation and averaging out market volatility.
- Advantages of SIP include rupee cost averaging, disciplined investing, and affordability with a minimum start of Rs 500.
- STP (Systematic Transfer Plan) enables transferring fixed amounts between mutual fund schemes, typically from debt to equity, helping manage risk and capitalize on market conditions.
- Advantages of STP include reduced volatility, tax efficiency through gradual transfers, and averaging risk similar to SIP.
- The key differences between SIP and STP are that SIP builds wealth in the long term while STP reallocates funds, with different taxation implications based on capital gains.
- SIP is suited for regular income investors, while STP is better suited for those wanting to rebalance investments.
- The choice between SIP or STP depends on individual financial goals, with SIP being preferable for salaried individuals and STP effective for lumpsum investors.
- For risk tolerance, SIP is better for risk-averse investors, while STP appeals to those seeking flexibility with lumpsums.
